"Oh, was is it a dream, or a prophecy?"
Puck to Golaith

Future Tense is the 43rd episode of season two, and 56th episode of Gargoyles. It debuted on April 25, 1996.


While attempting to return to Manhattan, Goliath is struck by lightning. When he regains consciousness, he and the other Avalon travelers discover that 40 years have passed, and Xanatos has wreaked havoc in the island. Goliath is rescued by an aged Matt Bluestone and Claw, but Elisa Maza and Angela are taken to the Eyrie Pyramid. They reveal that Hudson died as the first resistance fighter, and Brooklyn leads the clan with Demona at his side, Broadway was blinded in a battle against Dr. Sevarius and the Ultrapack, and Lexington has added cybernetic pieces to his body.

Throughout the battles against Xanatos and his various minions, such as Talon cyborgs, Thailog cyborgs, and Steel Clan robots, Goliath repeatedly refuses to use the Phoenix Gate to change history despite prompting from his various allies. The Gargoyles of Manhattan revel a man on the inside, Alexander "Fox" Xanatos, who intends to dethrone or usurp his father, but is killed at the penultimate moment somewhere in cyberspace. During the climactic battle, almost all of Goliath's allies are destroyed, and Xanatos is revealed to be a computer program modeled after Xanatos and created by the cybernetic Lexington, who has been utilizing it for years to control The Sovereign Nation of Manhattan and prepare a conquest of the entire world.

After escaping the Eyrie building, Elisa desperately and repeatedly demands the Phoenix Gate from a badly wounded Goliath; he realizes it's all been a ruse and the entire landscape disappears around him, revealing only Puck. Puck explains that with the coming of the Gathering, he needs the Gate to bribe Oberon in return for his freedom. The entire dream was a ruse to get Goliath to give it to him. Goliath wakes up, leaving him to wonder if Puck's landscape was an illusion... or a prophecy. Goliath uses the Gate to open a portal and send it randomly into the time stream, perhaps never to wash ashore again. He then redoubles his resolve to return to Manhattan.


Production Notes

Series continuity

  • This episode features the first appearances of the Xanatos Program and Alexander Fox Xanatos (Illusion).
  • This episode marks the first appearance of Puck, as himself, since The Mirror.
  • At the end of the episode, Goliath activates the Phoenix Gate, and releases it, without a mind to guide it.
    • At the time it was believed that this would result in it being lost in time and forever out of reach of any who would misuse it. However it instead lead to the events of the TimeDancer spinoff story line. In short a loop in time was created, wherein the Gate fell into the possession of The Archmage, and later Brooklyn, before finally returning to the point it had started at sometime before the start of the entire Gargoyles story.
  • Puck concocted the ruse in order to retrieve the Phoenix Gate, as Oberon's Law prevented him from out-and-out taking it.
    • However both Goliath and Puck mention the possibility that the events of Future Tense could as easily be portent as illusion.

World of "Future Tense"

The world of "Future Tense" is a dark and bleak alternate future set in the year 2036, which only existed in a vision that Puck conjured up to dupe Goliath into giving him the Phoenix Gate.

In Puck's nightmarish illusion, Xanatos took advantage of Goliath and Elisa's absence from New York to grow increasingly stronger, until, by 2004, he seized control of Manhattan, breaking it away from the rest of the United States and turning it into his private domain. The gargoyles fought desperately to stop him from doing so, but failed; Hudson attacked Xanatos in single combat, and was slain. However, Xanatos was also slain in the battle. Only Lexington knew this, however, and he chose to keep it secret. By this time, Lexington had somehow become corrupt and power-hungry, and decided to step into the void left by Xanatos upon his death; he created a "Xanatos Program" to masquerade as Xanatos. This program not only duplicated Xanatos's style perfectly (if even more cold-bloodedly ruthless than its original), but, by preserving the illusion that Xanatos was still alive (for the program produced holographic images of Xanatos giving public broadcasts to the city), it also allowed "Xanatos" to serve as a "front man" for Lexington, who was thus able to remain a member of the resistance and track and/or impede its progress.

During the time leading up to 2036, numerous disasters befell the clan, their allies, and Manhattan, although we do not know where they took place on the timeline, nor which of them took place before Xanatos and Hudson's deaths and Lexington's takeover, and which took place afterwards. The clock tower was destroyed and the gargoyles forced to take refuge in the Labyrinth. Xanatos (or Lexington masquerading as Xanatos) set up a fresh Mutate program under Sevarius, turning the humans of New York into Mutate soldiers in vast numbers; Broadway, Talon, Maggie, and Coldstone finally went up against Sevarius and the Ultra Pack (presumably a freshly upgraded version of the Pack) to put a stop to this, but all of them except for Broadway were slain, and he himself was blinded. Thailog was slain in the "Clone Wars", but Xanatos or Lexington masquerading as Xanatos produced a number of subservient clones of his as Thailog Shock Troops, to guard Castle Wyvern. After Thailog's death, Demona joined forces with the clan, presumably with the realization that they would have to put aside their quarrel in order to survive against the tyrant who had usurped the government of Manhattan. She eventually became Brooklyn's mate. Claw lost his wings in an unspecified battle, and Lexington became cybernetized (perhaps in battle and/or perhaps to assist him in his secret rule over the city).

By 2036, New York was a city in ruins, only a shadow of its former self. Mutate soldiers and Steel Clan robots (the latter redesigned to sport Xanatos's goatee on their faces) patrolled it constantly, while the remaining citizens lived a miserable life on the streets, reduced to eating rats. Brooklyn had become the leader of a resistance movement in the Labyrinth, consisting of, besides himself, Lexington, Broadway, Demona, Matt Bluestone, Claw, and a grown-up Alexander Xanatos who had become thoroughly horrified and disgusted with his father's actions. Lexington continued to run the Xanatos Program in secret, planning now for the final coup; he would release it over the Internet, seizing control of every computer on the planet, and thus become dictator over the whole Earth. He had already advanced the defenses of Castle Wyvern, including the raising of the enormous Eyrie Pyramid above it.

It was at this point in 2036 that Goliath and his companions returned to the island. The skiff was destroyed and sunk by the city's defenses, and Elisa and Angela were captured by Steel Clan robots and taken to the castle. Goliath and Bronx were rescued by Matt and Claw, however, and taken to the Labyrinth. There they met the other members of the resistance, and learned of the horrible events that had befallen Manhattan.

In the meantime, Alexander had penetrated the Eyrie Building to battle the Xanatos Program in cyberspace, only to be destroyed by it; in so doing, the computer program learned the whereabouts of the resistance's headquarters (though clearly since Lexington was playing both sides of the conflict, he already knew the location, so perhaps he revealed that the location was leaked to the Xanatos Program to encourage the resistance to leave the Labyrinth and attack the Eyrie Pyramid). However, before Alexander died, he was able to transmit his location back to the resistance, which used the information to launch a desperate attack on the Eyrie Building. Matt, Bronx, and Claw assaulted the building on the ground level, while the gargoyles swooped in from above. But Matt, Bronx, and Claw were disintegrated by the Mutate ground troops, while the gargoyles were attacked by the Thailog Shock Troops in Castle Wyvern's courtyard; Lexington was "captured" (actually, he had arranged this to happen so that he could quietly get to the computer to launch the Xanatos Program globally), and Broadway was killed. Goliath, Brooklyn, and Demona entered the great hall of the castle, only to be transported into cyberspace, where Elisa and Angela were already being held captive. There, they came face to face with the Xanatos Program, learning its true nature. The Program created a cybernetic sun, turning the gargoyles to stone, shattered Brooklyn and Angela to fragments, and then disintegrated Demona (who, even in cyberspace, still became a human when the sun rose). Goliath, however, broke free from his stone prison to save himself and Elisa and flee cyberspace, only to discover that Lexington had launched the Xanatos Program all over the world, and that it was too late to abort this procedure. Goliath, in his ensuing fury, slew Lexington and set off an explosion which destroyed the Eyrie Building, then fled from it with Elisa. However, with the Xanatos Program continuing to spread across the world even after Lexington's death, there seemed no way to avert it, except, according to Elisa, by time travel with the Phoenix Gate.

Goliath had been badly wounded in the escape from the Eyrie Building, and even if he had been in any condition to use the Gate, he knew that it would do no good: history is immutable. Still, he was willing to let Elisa try. But when Elisa insisted that he place the Gate in her hand, he became suspicious. And the more suspicious he became the more desperate Elisa's pleas were, and the more strength Goliath regained -- until the whole illusion unraveled around Puck. And so at last, Goliath learned the truth from Puck, that it had all been an illusion, created to obtain the Phoenix Gate. (In fact, throughout the illusion, Puck had used one or another of the principals in his dark drama to urge Goliath to turn over the Phoenix Gate to somebody, Elisa's demand being only the last of these.) Puck left, his scheme having been foiled, though not before asking Goliath "Was it a dream, or a prophecy?" - and refusing to answer his own question.

A Dream or a Prophecy?

So which was it? On the surface level: definitely a dream. Goliath and his companions returned to New York shortly afterwards to indeed find that it was still 1996 there, and their arrival forty years earlier than 2036 would be enough to show that the "Future Tense prophecy" will not be literally fulfilled. But on other levels, parts of the vision have been achieved, hinted at, or otherwise come true in one form or another. Below is a rundown of the links between the World of "Future Tense" and the real Gargoyles Universe:

  • Alexander Fox Xanatos - Alex was referred to as both Alexander and Fox in the episode and Alex was indeed born to David Xanatos and Fox shortly after the episode took place. In his function as Owen Burnett, Puck would be well aware of what name Xanatos and Fox were intending to give their son, and so would most likely have been drawing from that source when he added Alexander to the weave. In the true Gargoyles Universe, it seems that Alex's future will be very different from that shown in "Future Tense".
  • The Clock Tower - Only months after Goliath had his vision, his life in the Clock Tower would end when it was destroyed, just as it had been in the vision. More interestingly, the building was damaged in the exact same manner (only the Clan's home in the upper region of the building and the clocks themselves were completely destroyed, and most of the rest of the building remained intact). The destruction of the clock tower is a logical element of any "doom-and-gloom" scenario for the gargoyles, although since Puck may not have known about the clock tower beforehand, its destruction may have been intended to move events to a location that would be easier to replicate. Within the "Future Tense" world, the method of the tower's destruction and the parties responsible were never revealed.
  • The Eyrie Pyramid - In Puck's vision, the Eyrie Building has been shown to be hugely expanded in size and technological sophistication and is now known as the Eyrie Pyramid. In the real Gargoyles Universe, the Eyrie Pyramid will exist in the same way by 2138  though whether it will look like it did in Puck's vision is not known. It is also possible that by 1996, David Xanatos had come up with the idea to expand the Eyrie Building into the Eyrie Pyramid and shared his vision with Owen but it had not yet gotten past the planning stage.
  • The Xanatos Program - Though there is nothing known as the Xanatos Program in Gargoyles reality, Puck's vision of this entity is very similar to the Coyote line of robots and computer program used in "Legion". Both feature Xanatos's facial appearances and voice, and both have been used to impersonate Xanatos himself, if darker and more vengeful and cruel. Puck is certainly aware of the Coyote robots before he creates the vision. However, Coyote's aspirations in the future have been hinted at as nothing less than total world (or even galactic) domination, something Coyote has shown no desire for when Puck created this illusion and is another prophetic link between the robot and the computer program.
  • Brooklyn - In "Future Tense" Brooklyn was shown as a confident and capable leader. While he was well on his way to this capacity ("Upgrade", "Kingdom", et al.) it seems that in the real Gargoyles Universe he will achieve this after forty years of separation from Goliath as well. Soon after returning to live at the Eyrie Building in 1996, Brooklyn began his TimeDancer adventures, bouncing around time and space with the help of the Phoenix for forty years before returning to where he started forty seconds after he had left. This is mirrored by Goliath and Brooklyn in "Future Tense"; Brooklyn does indeed have a forty year separation from Goliath, though it is Goliath who jumped through time, not Brooklyn. When Brooklyn returned from his TimeDancing, he bore some resemblance to his "Future Tense" counterpart, including the futuristic breastplate - but also sported an eyepatch, which the Brooklyn of "Future Tense" lacked. Puck's powers of prediction can here again be called into question. Since history is immutable, Brooklyn's adventures in the past had already occurred. The image of an older Brooklyn could have been based on a secondhand description or actual encounter Puck had with an older Brooklyn in the past. The forty years that Brooklyn spent TimeDancing could well have only a coincidental similarity to Goliath's forty years of absence from New York, particularly given the traditional mystical significance of the number forty (the rain that caused Noah's Flood lasted for forty days and forty nights, the Israelites under Moses spent forty years wandering in the wilderness on the journey from Egypt to Israel, etc.); it is also worth noting that the differences between the two events are as strong as (if not stronger than) the similarities.
  • Demona - In Puck's illusion, Demona had joined the side of the Manhattan Clan and its allies in a resistance movement. All of this would eventually be seen to come true in the Gargoyles: 2198 spin-off. And just as in the vision, there may be some doubt about whether she is indeed an ally or an enemy. Demona's love for her daughter Angela is also mentioned in the vision, something she had not yet shown. Her working with Goliath to save Angela's life would again be seen in "The Reckoning".
  • Brooklyn and Demona's relationship - Puck showed Brooklyn and Demona to have become mates at some point during Goliath's forty year absence. Though this will never actually occur, it does have a parallel in the couple's clones. Brooklyn's clone, Malibu, and Demona's pseudo-clone, Delilah, seem to have formed the beginnings of a relationship in "Bash", though more information is unavailable at this time. Furthermore, Brooklyn and Demona will work together in the resistance movement in the Gargoyles: 2198 spin-off similarly to Puck's vision.
  • Thailog - When Puck created the vision he did not realize Demona and Thailog were together, so it probably does not count as a confirmed prediction that they are no longer together. That said, the Thailog Shook Troops and mention of the Clone Wars does cause one to wonder if these were a prophecy themselves. Certainly, Thailog's actions and motivations in "Bash" point to something terrible coming of the DNA samples stolen from the Manhattan Clan, though there is only speculation at this point.
  • The Ultra-pack - At the time of Puck's vision to Goliath, the remaining members of the Pack (Coyote, Hyena, Jackal, and Wolf) had split apart and gone their own separate ways. The reformation of the (probably upgraded) Ultra-Pack was guessed or prophesied by Puck very closely. Indeed, these four members and a new member will be formed in the future and upgraded, making them more dangerous than ever. The exact details of this event are unknown. Puck could certainly have predicted that the Pack would be upgraded again, since it had already been upgraded once.
  • Sevarius - In Puck's vision, Brooklyn briefly mentioned that Dr. Sevarius had continued to create mutates and had fought in a battle to keep the remaining humans of New York from being turned into mutates. Moreover, armies of mutate soldiers patrolled the streets of the city in the vision. Indeed, Sevarius would go on to make more mutates in "Louse" as predicted. Furthermore, his scheme at that time was to mutate large numbers of Manhattan citizens to experiment with the makings of an army of mutate soldiers. The similarities here cannot be ignored.
  • Lexington - Lexington represented one of the darkest aspects of Puck's vision. Fortunately, it does not seem that the real Lexington will become what his dark counterpart was. However, here again are many interesting links. Just a few months after Goliath had this vision, Lexington wore a cyborg costume to a Halloween party, and it was strikingly similar to his look in "Future Tense" (since the costume was a gift from Fox, it is entirely possible that Owen had a hand in its design, one must wonder what Goliath's reaction to the costume was, but, alas, none was shown). Furthermore, in the future Lexington will work closely with the Xanatos family and eventually go into business for himself and assist in forming the Lexington-Xanatos Corporation which has its headquarters in the Eyrie Pyramid, with the similarities to Puck's vision being obvious. In the future this company will also produce the LXM robots, which look and sound like Lexington, only having metallic chrome bodies. This too echos Lexington's appearance in "Future Tense". One must also mention Brentwood, Lexington's clone. In "Bash" Brentwood chose to join forces with Thailog over his clan-mates and has thus joined into Thailog's world of manipulation and scheming, all too similar to the Lexington of "Future Tense" and his joining the Machiavellian world of Xanatos. Indeed, Greg Weisman has stated that "one only has to look at "Future Tense" to see the direction that Brentwood is heading."

Could Puck have been perhaps tapping into the real future of the Gargoyles Universe when he created the vision?

With all these similarities, one must note that it is also worth pointing out that we already know that some of the predictions in "Future Tense" will not come true. Not only did Goliath return safely to New York in 1996 rather than 2036, but Xanatos called off his war upon the clan the same night, because Goliath had helped save Alexander from Oberon. It is therefore extremely unlikely that he will undertake the proceedings that led to the conquest and enslavement of Manhattan. Aside from that, Xanatos's actions during "Future Tense" seem very melodramatic and out of character for him, indeed even Goliath stated that the real Xanatos at his worst would not have done what the program did. Perhaps this was Puck's way of poking fun at his human form's boss, or perhaps he was playing into Goliath's poor opinions of Xanatos. According to what we know of the distant future of the Gargoyles Universe, furthermore, many of the principals involved in the events in "Future Tense" will lead very different lives. Alexander, far from being killed in 2036, will still be alive by 2198. So will Demona (her death in Puck's vision is impossible, in any case, since only Macbeth can slay her). Broadway and Angela, at least, will survive to the middle of the 21st century and possibly beyond, given the birth-dates of their three biological children.

So the dark future in the nightmare that Puck gave Goliath will almost certainly not come to pass in full, although it is likely that further ingredients of it may surface over the years. It is most likely that Puck's comment was nothing more than a teasing taunt to annoy and alarm Goliath. Most likely.


  • This episode carries several allusions:
  • to the Days of Future Past story arc in the X-Men comic series
  • to Shakespeare's Hamlet
  • to Monty Python's Holy Grail
  • It is also a perfect example of the "Bad Future" or dystopian future trope; where a character's single action or absence leads to catastrophic or even apocalyptic results.

Memorable Quotes

  • "Goliath, the sun... it's... so... beautiful..." - Broadway
  • Xanatos: Alas, poor Goliath, I knew him well.
Goliath: You will not win.
Xanatos: What are you going to do? Bite my kneecaps off?
  • "Oh, was is it a dream, or a prophecy?"
"I must know!"
"Uh-huh, like I'd tell you." - Puck and Goliath


Season 1 Season 2 Season 3

  1. Awakening
  2. Awakening, Part Two
  3. Awakening, Part Three
  4. Awakening, Part Four
  5. Awakening, Part Five
  6. The Thrill of the Hunt
  7. Temptation
  8. Deadly Force
  9. Enter MacBeth
10. The Edge
11. Long Way to Morning
12. Her Brother's Keeper
13. Reawakening

  1. Leader of the Pack
  2. Metamorphosis
  3. Legion
  4. A Lighthouse in the Sea of Time
  5. The Mirror
  6. The Silver Falcon
  7. Eye of the Beholder
  8. Vows
  9. City of Stone, Part One
10. City of Stone, Part Two
11. City of Stone, Part Three
12. City of Stone, Part Four
13. High Noon

14. Outfoxed
15. The Price
16. Revelations
17. Double Jeopardy
18. Upgrade
19. Protection
20. The Cage
21. Avalon, Part One
22. Avalon, Part Two
23. Avalon, Part Three
24. Shadows of the Past
25. Heritage
26. Monsters

27. Golem
28. Sanctuary
29. M.I.A.
30. Grief
31. Kingdom
32. The Hound of Ulster
33. Walkabout
34. Mark of the Panther
35. Pendragon
36. Eye of the Storm
37. The New Olympians
38. The Green
39. Sentinel

40. Bushido
41. Cloud Fathers
42. Ill Met By Moonlight
43. Future Tense
44. The Gathering, Part One
45. The Gathering, Part Two
46. Vendettas
47. Turf
48. The Reckoning
49. Possession
50. Hunter's Moon, Part One
51. Hunter's Moon, Part Two
52. Hunter's Moon, Part Three

  1. The Journey
  2. Ransom
  3. Runaways
  4. Broadway Goes Hollywood
  5. A Bronx Tail
  6. The Dying Of The Light
  7. And Justice For All
  8. Genesis Undone
  9. Generations
10. ...For It May Come True
11. To Serve Mankind
12. Seeing Isn't Believing
13. Angels In The Night

SLG comic books

Gargoyles #1. Clan Building Chapter One: Nightwatch
Gargoyles #2. Clan Building Chapter Two: The Journey
Gargoyles #3. Clan Building Chapter Three: Invitation Only
Gargoyles #4. Clan Building Chapter Four: Masque
Gargoyles #5. Clan Building Chapter Five: Bash
Gargoyles #6. Clan Building Chapter Six: Reunion
Gargoyles #7. Clan Building Chapter Seven: The Rock
Gargoyles #8. Clan Building Chapter Eight: Rock & Roll
Gargoyles #9. Clan Building Chapter Nine: Rock of Ages
Gargoyles #10. Clan Building Chapter Ten: The Gate
Gargoyles #11. Clan Building Chapter Eleven: Tyrants
Gargoyles #12. Clan Building Chapter Twelve: Phoenix

Bad Guys #1. Strangers
Bad Guys #2. The Lost
Bad Guys #3. Estranged
Bad Guys #4. Louse
Bad Guys #5. Strangled
Bad Guys #6. Losers

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.